Windermere Island Buying Property in Windermere Island

Windermere Island: Private Island Hideaway

When you want true privacy in the Caribbean, you don’t just buy any waterfront property – you look for somewhere genuinely secluded, protected, and exclusive. Windermere Island delivers all three, which explains why everyone from oceanographer Jacques Cousteau to Diana, Princess of Wales, and King Charles III chose this hidden sanctuary for their honeymoon, drawn by the same combination of absolute privacy and natural beauty that continues to attract discerning homeowners today.

This tiny private paradise is tucked away near Savannah Sound in central Eleuthera, just five square miles of pure tranquility protected by a five-mile reef that keeps the crowds at bay and the waters crystal clear. The moment you cross the guarded bridge – your gateway to this gated community – you enter a world where privacy isn’t just expected, it’s guaranteed. Here, a small, friendly group of homeowners shares something truly special: an unhurried way of life that feels worlds away from the everyday rush, yet is surprisingly accessible with Governor’s Harbour and Rock Sound airports just 30 to 40 minutes away.

Five-Mile Pink Sand Beach

Jacques Cousteau knew a thing or two about beautiful places, so when he declared Windermere Island’s beach one of the most beautiful in the world, people took notice. That five-mile stretch of pink sand isn’t just gorgeous to look at – it’s yours to explore without bumping into crowds of tourists or fighting for a good spot. The pink hue comes from tiny coral fragments mixed with the white sand, creating that distinctive blush that looks different at every hour of the day.

The reef that protects this coastline does more than just create calm waters perfect for swimming. It’s become a destination in itself for those who love snorkeling and diving, offering an underwater world that rivals the beauty above the surface. You’re not just buying a home here; you’re gaining access to your own private marine sanctuary.

Members-Only Island Living

Every homeowner on Windermere automatically becomes part of the Windermere Island Owners Association, which sounds formal but really just means you get access to the island’s crown jewel: the members-only club. This isn’t your typical country club. It’s a casual-chic gathering place where you can sip on a drink at the bar, enjoy a meal in the dining room, work out in the gym, take a dip in the pool, or play a game of tennis. You get all the amenities of a luxury resort, but it’s exclusively yours, your neighbors’ and your guests’ to enjoy. No reservations needed, no crowds to navigate – just easy island living at its finest.

Celebrity Hideaway

It’s no wonder Windermere has become a haven for celebrities seeking genuine privacy. Toni Braxton found her escape here, as did India Hicka and Jacques Cousteau himself, who made it his home base for years. Windermere offers something increasingly rare in today’s connected world. True privacy, natural beauty, and a sense of exclusivity that money alone can’t buy. The round-the-clock guarded bridge ensures that only residents and their invited guests can access the island, creating a sanctuary where famous faces can relax without worry.

Windermere Island Real Estate

The property for sale in Windermere Island match the exclusivity of the location itself. Discover luxury beach houses set directly on the beach as well as luxury waterfront homes with private docks for buyers who want direct access to the water. For those who prefer to build from scratch, prime beachfront and waterfront land parcels offer the chance to create your dream home exactly as you envision it. Whether that means an infinity pool overlooking the beach or a dock designed for your superyacht, these lots give you complete creative freedom on one of the Caribbean’s most exclusive islands.

Privacy Perfected

Tiny and secluded, with an astoundingly beautiful pink sand beach stretching as far as the eye can see, and equally stunning luxury homes, Windermere Island offers the ultimate in exclusivity and privacy. The properties here are far more than a place to live – they are your gateway to a less hurried pace of life where you can completely unwind in complete privacy. Whether you are looking for a luxury vacation retreat or a permanent residence, Windermere Island is the perfect place to escape from the world in barefoot chic luxury.